Supreme Court Turns Aside Challenge to Whitaker as Acting Attorney General

WASHINGTON (The Washington Post) -
Matthew Whitaker
Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker (AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall, File)

The Supreme Court, without comment, turned away a challenge Monday to Matt Whitaker’s appointment as acting attorney general.

Washington lawyer and Supreme Court practitioner Thomas Goldstein has intervened in cases in Nevada and Maryland to say that President Donald Trump did not have the legal authority to appoint Whitaker, who had served as chief of staff to former attorney general Jeff Sessions.

The justices denied the Nevada case and its attempt to substitute Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein for Whitaker. The Maryland case is still before a federal judge there.

Goldstein and others say that Rosenstein, the department’s number two official, should have succeeded Sessions, and that it is unlawful for Whitaker to be running the department for even a short time.

They brought the issue to the Supreme Court in a case brought by Barry Michaels. He was challenging a law that prevents him from buying a firearm because of a previous nonviolent crime.

Maryland Attorney General Brian Frosh, in coordination with Goldstein, has also challenged the validity of Whitaker’s appointment in a pending case in federal court in Baltimore. U.S. District Judge Ellen Hollander has not yet ruled on the state’s motion to replace Whitaker with Rosenstein.

The lawsuit seeks to force the Trump administration to uphold a key section of the Affordable Care Act.

Hollander has not said when she would issue a decision, but the court’s action will surely affect her decision.

At a hearing in December, the judge suggested that a ruling invalidating Whitaker’s appointment would be inconsistent with past court decisions.

“Wouldn’t I be an outlier if I agreed with you?” she asked Goldstein at the hearing.

Since the filings, President Trump has nominated William Barr to replace Sessions as attorney general. His confirmation hearings in the Senate are scheduled to begin soon.