Feds Appoint Monitor Over Troubled NYC Public Housing

Mayor Bill de Blasio and HUD Secretary Benjamin Carson announce and sign an agreement to improve NYCHA in New York on January 31, 2019. (Michael Appleton/Mayoral Photography Office)

New York City and U.S. housing officials announced a deal Thursday that will keep the city’s massive public housing system out of federal receivership, but require the city to spend $2.2 billion over the next few years fixing chronic problems with lousy living conditions, lead paint and lack of heat.

The settlement, announced by U.S. Housing Secretary Ben Carson and Mayor Bill de Blasio, resolves a lawsuit in which federal authorities filed on behalf of the system’s 400,000 tenants.

It would put the New York City Housing Authority under the eye of a federal monitor, but stop short of a solution suggested by a federal judge last fall, which would be to take the system out of the city’s hands and place it under federal control.

Carson called the agreement a “positive outcome” for the nation’s largest public housing system. De Blasio, a Democrat, called it “a partnership to get things done for the residents.”

Carson, the top housing official in Republican President Donald Trump’s administration, said that he and the Democratic mayor “were able to put aside any political differences and think about, what would provide the right kind of environment for the people here?”

De Blasio, who joined Carson at the announcement in Manhattan, said Carson “has shown me a level of focus and concern that I deeply appreciate..”

Tenants in the system have complained for decades about rodents, mold and heat and hot water outages. Authority chairwoman Shola Olatoye resigned last year after an investigation revealed years of falsified reports about lead paint inspections.

An earlier $2 billion deal between the city and federal government was rejected by U.S. District Judge William Pauley in November after the judge said it wouldn’t do enough to improve conditions. He suggested the federal government should take over the authority and gave the city a mid-December deadline to file papers outlining a repair plan to avert it. The deadline was later extended to Jan. 31.

Under the agreement announced Thursday, the lawsuit will be withdrawn 14 days after the appointment of a federal monitor. The city will pay for the monitor, who will submit regular reports to the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development.

The agreement requires the authority, known by the acronym NYCHA, to meet specific deadlines and benchmarks for addressing health and safety hazards including lead paint, mold and lack of heat. For example, NYCHA will have 30 days to “eliminate any lead-based paint hazards” in apartments where children under 6 live or regularly visit. A new leader will be chosen to replace Stanley Brezenoff.

Asked how the agreement differed from the consent decree that Pauley rejected, de Blasio said, “You will see this has a whole host of tangible goals on heat, vermin, lead, you name it. I think that’s an improvement for all of us.”