NY Village Takes The Choking Out Of Its Official Seal

The old seal (L) and the new rendering of the seal of the village of Whitesboro, NY. (Village of Whitesboro)

More than 200 years after local lore says a settler named Hugh White bested an Oneida Indian in a friendly wrestling match, he’s still grappling with his opponent — at least on an upstate New York village’s newly revised official seal.

Whitesboro found itself making national news in early 2016 when it held a public vote on whether to change the village seal, which depicted a white man besting a Native American in a hand-to-hand struggle. Some considered the image racist and insensitive, and an online petition to get the seal changed led to the non-binding vote, which ended with 157 residents voting to leave the seal alone, out of 212 votes cast.

But after the vote, village officials said they would change the seal, which appeared to show a white man choking his Indian opponent. The newly released seal, designed by a student at an art school in nearby Utica, features better graphics but still depicts a white man — village founder White — going head-to-head in a wrestling stance with an Oneida, albeit one who’s clothing and headdress are more historically correct than the buckskin breeches-wearing Indian in the old seal.

“We didn’t have a problem with the wrestling match” theme remaining in the new seal, Dana Nimey-Olney, clerk and registrar for the village, said Wednesday.

According to local historians, in the late 1700s, White settled the village that would bear his name and established good relations with the local Oneida tribe. When one of the Indians challenged him to a friendly wrestling match, White threw and pinned his opponent.

“It was how they became friendly,” Nimey-Olney said. “They wanted each other’s respect through things like this wrestling match.”

The new seal has been placed on village vehicles, signs and buildings.

The January 2016 vote to keep the traditional seal caught the attention of a national comedy show that mocked the vote’s outcome in a segment on the controversy. Other media outlets covered the issue, bringing national attention to the sleepy village of 80 miles northwest of Albany.

It wasn’t the first time someone sought to change the seal. The village was sued over the seal by a Native American group in 1977. The village altered the seal slightly, but kept the wrestling image intact.