OPINION: East Ramapo Deal in Jeopardy as NY Chancellor Rejects School Budget

East Ramapo, NY Chancellor, School Budget
A public school in East Ramapo. (Hamodia Photo)

East Ramapo is a unique school district; it is located in Rockland County, which has the second-highest real estate taxes in the nation. It consists of approximately 8,500 public school students and 25,500 nonpublic school students.

It is one of the poorest school districts in New York, but because of the unfair formula the state uses, it does not include the nonpublic school students in its calculations. It therefore considers East Ramapo a rich district, and it therefore loses tens of millions of dollars annually in funds from Albany.

The nonpublic school parents pay tuition to educate their children in the private schools, as well as paying school taxes. As good citizens, the nonpublic school parents passed the budget during the past few years, since Governor Cuomo put a cap on tax increases.

We even made sure that a $60 million bond passed with an approximate $30 million reimbursement from the state, and $30 million left for taxpayers to pay.

Not a cent of the money went to private schools; being conscientious citizens, we approved the bond issue.

Because of the shortfall in the budget, the politicians in Albany voted to give an additional $3 million per year to the East Ramapo school district, with an oversight to make sure that not a cent goes to the nonpublic schools.

We conservatively figure that over 70 percent of the real-estate-tax money in East Ramapo comes from the nonpublic school community.

Another school district in Rockland County, the North Rockland school district, is also very tight for money. Even though it does not have as many problems as East Ramapo, our local politicians had no problem asking the state for an additional grant of over $6 million.

After willingly paying so much in taxes and approving the $60 million bond, what did the East Ramapo school board ask as quid pro quo? Five days of non-mandated busing for private schools on days that the public schools are closed. After reimbursement, the total cost of the five days is approximately $135,000; coming out of a budget of $230 million, it is about one-twentieth of one percent — a drop in the bucket.

We were told that the commissioner answered that we will never get extra busing until public schools get everything that they require. That statement is very misleading. The public schools in the East Ramapo school district get everything that is mandated by law, as do the nonpublic schools. No school district ever gets everything that it wants, but the public schools in East Ramapo currently get many non-mandated services.

The commissioner has oversight of approximately 700 school districts in the state of New York. By zeroing in on East Ramapo and trying to micromanage it, even though it has done nothing illegal, the school board made a bad judgment call, giving a miniscule portion of the budget to help nonpublic schools.

And this was only after the board managed to get its nonpublic-school parents to pass the budget and the bond issue, and give many non-mandated items to the public schools.

The commissioner still refuses to give five additional days of transportation, showing her as insensitive to the needs of all the district’s students.

The school board that has to deal with the parents and students of public and nonpublic schools on a daily basis has been overridden by the commissioner in Albany, 120 miles away. We do not know what else, if anything, the commissioner has in mind.

The taxpayers in the district, after going the extra mile to help the public schools and voting for a school board to carry out their hopes for the district, have just received a slap in the face. We have just seen that for even minor issues we have been disenfranchised.

We have no option open to us other than to defeat the budget and send a message to Albany.

Kalman Weber is president of the South East Ramapo Taxpayers Association.