Online Shopping Grows, With Some Growing Pains

Americans waited until the last minute to do year-end shopping, but retailers weren’t prepared for the spike.

Heavy spending in the final days of the mostly lackluster season sent sales up 3.5 percent between Nov. 1 and Tuesday, according to MasterCard Advisors SpendingPulse, which tracks payments but doesn’t give dollar figures.

Online shopping led the uptick, with spending up 10 percent to $38. 91 billion between Nov. 2 and Sunday, research firm comScore said.

“We always have last-minute Charlies, but this year even people who normally complete shopping earlier, completed shopping later,” said Marshal Cohen, chief retail analyst at market research firm NPD Group.

The late surge caught companies off guard. UPS and FedEx failed to deliver some packages on time, due to a combination of poor weather and overloaded systems, leaving some unhappy shoppers.

Justin Londagin and his wife ordered, for  their 7-year-old son, a football jersey online on Dec. 19. They paid $12.95 extra for two-day shipping to their Augusta, Kan., home, but it didn’t arrive within that time frame.

Amazon is offering customers with delayed shipments a refund on their shipping charges, and $20 toward a future purchase. And other retailers such as Macy’s said they are looking into the situation.

The last-minute surge this year solidifies the increasing popularity of online shopping, which accounts for about 10 percent of sales during the last three months of the year. It also underscores the challenges that companies face, delivering on the experience, particularly during the year-end shopping season that runs from the beginning of November through December.

Analysts say FedEx and UPS typically work closely with big retailers to get a sense of the volume of packages they’ll handle during peak times. Extra flights, trucks and temporary workers can be added, if the projections are large.

But this year, David Vernon, a senior research analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein, said weather played a role. The early December ice storms in Dallas could have hurt operations, he said, and packages can start to accumulate. And that got compounded by a late surge in shipments, he said.

“Clearly, as a group, (they) underestimated the demand for internet retailing during the year-end shopping season,” Vernon said.

Another problem was the growing popularity of retailers offering free shipping. Amazon, for one, has a two-day free shipping offer that comes with its $79 annual Prime membership. The company said that in the third week of December alone, more than 1 million people signed up for the membership.

“Frankly, the right hand wasn’t talking to the left,” said Forrester analyst Sucharita Mulpuru. “The marketing teams of a lot of web retailers (offering free shipping) were not talking to the operations and supply chain teams.”

The resulting delayed shipments could be a problem for shippers. UPS and FedEx did not quantify how many packages were affected, but said they were just a small fraction of total deliveries.

“The central pillar of their business is a perception of reliability with their customers,” said Jeremy Robinson-Leon, CEO of Group Gordon, a corporate and crisis PR firm. This year’s snafus “just really eroded trust among customers.”

Still, analysts say people will still shop online. “Consumers tend to have a short memory, especially if you fast forward to another year,” said Andrew Lipsman, vice president of industry analysis for comScore.

Indeed, some shoppers are taking the delays in stride. Traci Arbios, who lives in Clovis, Calif., did about 90 percent of her shopping online. Most items included free shipping and everything arrived on time, except one package she ordered from a seller on eBay that was sent first class by the U.S. Postal Service on Dec. 12. It still had not arrived on Thursday.

“Everything arrived on time except this one item,” she said. “It’s not going to stop me from shopping online.”