What John F. Kennedy Was — and Wasn’t

Now, 50 years after Kennedy’s assassination, that answer still seems relevant.

Kennedy was a compartmentalized man with much to hide, comfortable with secrets and lies. He organized his White House as a wagon wheel, with himself as what he called “the vital center,” the hub. All of his relations along the spokes were bilateral. “It was instinctive at first,” he said. “I had different identities, and this was a useful way of expressing each without compromising the others.”

Debate about those identities, and about what kind of president Kennedy really was, has dominated the discussion in advance of the anniversary of his death. Professors and pundits tend to downgrade Kennedy’s legacy, seeing him as an ordinary, even ineffective leader. But the American people — or at least three-quarters of them, according to polling done this month by the Gallup organization — rate him as the greatest of modern presidents.

Historians and scholars do not rank Kennedy with the top tier of presidents… And their assessment is starting to influence the history books that students read in school. The New York Times, in a long front-page story by Adam Clymer, recently reported that high school textbooks, unlike those of an earlier era, no longer portray Kennedy as a tragic hero.

“In general, the picture has evolved from a charismatic young president who inspired youths around the world to a deeply flawed one whose oratory outstripped his accomplishments,” wrote Clymer. “Averting war in the Cuban missile crisis got less attention and respect. Legislative setbacks and a deepening commitment in Vietnam got more. The Kennedy-era glamour seemed more image than reality.” And others have focused recently on how Kennedy’s deeds never matched his soaring rhetoric.

But image counts, and so do words. Kennedy, like Roosevelt and Ronald Reagan, understood that words and images are the way to reach millions of people. The president’s job is to lead the nation, not manage the government, which is unmanageable. Nobody remembers whether Lincoln balanced the budget.

Kennedy probably doesn’t belong on a list of the top five presidents. But I would put him near the top of the next list. Although he served less than three years, he was the most important man in the world at a critical time, the man in charge at a hinge-point in national and world politics, diplomacy and war — at home and abroad.

At the end of his days, he had his share of historic achievements: He prevented regional wars in Cuba and Germany, and possibly even World War III. He put the government on the side of the minority in the black struggle for civil rights — no small act of political courage when his own party, the Democrats, controlled the segregated Southern states and Congress. He gambled confidently that the United States could overtake the Soviets’ early lead in space exploration, mobilizing the nation by pledging that an American would walk on the moon before the end of the 1960s. (And we did it!) He negotiated a nuclear test ban treaty with the Soviet Union, the first of the nuclear age…

Yes, he also had his disasters. He recklessly approved an invasion of Cuba in 1961 at the Bay of Pigs, and he foolishly did the same in signing off on the overthrow of President Ngo Dinh Diem of South Vietnam in 1963, leaving the United States stupidly overcommitted in Southeast Asia and backing military dictators…

Kennedy also changed the way we choose our leaders. He ignored and destroyed the structure of party bosses and conventions, winning the Democratic nomination by traveling the country, building his own state organizations and winning over the national political media… He built the model of modern presidential ambition and campaigning, demonstrating that the crucial qualification for the top job was wanting it.

He also inspired and organized a generation ready for something new, the young veterans of World War II… He did not wear hats, and soon enough no men did. He wore his hair long, and soon we all did. He promoted optimism in the people who elected him.

He was irresistible to millions around the world; the story was classic tragedy, the young prince struck down, an athlete dying young. It became the stuff of its own myths and legends, carefully cultivated by his wife, his family and his followers. And the legends have faded slowly. In that Gallup poll taken this month, the Americans that most admired Kennedy were those in the age group 18 to 29.

So there is every chance they will be showing and telling this story 50 years from now.

This article appeared in print on page 10 of the November 22nd, 2013 edition of Hamodia.